EcoEnclose vs Fantastapack

Custom mailer boxes · prices checked Nov 2, 2026

The short answer

EcoEnclose is cheaper at 31 of 36 price points we checked.

EcoEnclose is better rated (4.5 / 5 from 61 reviews).

Only Fantastapack prints full color; EcoEnclose prints 1–2 colors on kraft.

Side by side

EcoEncloseFantastapack
Trustpilot rating4.5 / 52.1 / 5
Reviews6117
Printing1–2 colorFull color
Smallest order1005
One-time fees$95–$125 by sizeNone
Standard production3–4 weeks10–15 business days
Rush option2–3 weeks for about 30% more7 days for 35% more on the order

Order totals

SizeBoxesEcoEncloseFantastapackCheaper
6 × 5 × 2.25100$368$292Fantastapack by $76
6 × 5 × 2.25250$533$600EcoEnclose by $68
6 × 5 × 2.25500$810$1,110EcoEnclose by $300
6 × 5 × 2.251,000$1,395$1,880EcoEnclose by $485
6 × 4 × 3100$389$318Fantastapack by $71
6 × 4 × 3250$580$713EcoEnclose by $133
6 × 4 × 3500$900$1,285EcoEnclose by $385
6 × 4 × 31,000$1,575$2,240EcoEnclose by $665
7 × 5 × 3100$412$341Fantastapack by $71
7 × 5 × 3250$630$820EcoEnclose by $190
7 × 5 × 3500$1,000$1,480EcoEnclose by $480
7 × 5 × 31,000$1,765$2,560EcoEnclose by $795
8 × 6 × 3100$435$395Fantastapack by $40
8 × 6 × 3250$685$928EcoEnclose by $242
8 × 6 × 3500$1,100$1,605EcoEnclose by $505
8 × 6 × 31,000$1,975$2,810EcoEnclose by $835
12 × 9 × 2100$490$447Fantastapack by $43
12 × 9 × 2250$773$1,045EcoEnclose by $272
12 × 9 × 2500$1,240$1,780EcoEnclose by $540
12 × 9 × 21,000$2,215$3,100EcoEnclose by $885
9.5 × 7.75 × 4100$546$633EcoEnclose by $87
9.5 × 7.75 × 4250$940$1,395EcoEnclose by $455
9.5 × 7.75 × 4500$1,585$2,410EcoEnclose by $825
9.5 × 7.75 × 41,000$2,935$4,110EcoEnclose by $1,175
10 × 8 × 4100$587$655EcoEnclose by $68
10 × 8 × 4250$995$1,445EcoEnclose by $450
10 × 8 × 4500$1,660$2,495EcoEnclose by $835
10 × 8 × 41,000$3,055$4,260EcoEnclose by $1,205
12 × 10 × 4100$653$783EcoEnclose by $130
12 × 10 × 4250$1,145$1,655EcoEnclose by $510
12 × 10 × 4500$1,945$2,900EcoEnclose by $955
12 × 10 × 41,000$3,635$5,100EcoEnclose by $1,465
14 × 10 × 4100$677$833EcoEnclose by $156
14 × 10 × 4250$1,203$1,725EcoEnclose by $523
14 × 10 × 4500$2,050$2,995EcoEnclose by $945
14 × 10 × 41,000$3,835$5,300EcoEnclose by $1,465

Totals include one-time fees. Shipping not included. Some suppliers only sell fixed amounts (like 240 instead of 250), so the winner is decided on price per box.

Our pick for: Eco materials and simple logos

EcoEnclose

Recycled kraft and well-liked service. Only prints 1–2 colors and adds a one-time plate fee, so it shines for simple logos at 250 boxes and up.

What reviewers say: Recycled kraft and well-liked service. Prints 1–2 colors, so best for a simple logo.

Full EcoEnclose reviewVisit EcoEnclose
Our pick for: Tiny test runs

Fantastapack

Lets you order as few as 5 boxes, which is handy for testing a design. It's among the priciest at larger sizes and has only a handful of mostly negative reviews, so order a sample before anything bigger.

What reviewers say: Very few reviews and mostly negative: short-shipped quantities, print problems and slow support, with the odd reviewer praising flexible timelines.

Full Fantastapack reviewVisit Fantastapack

Prices by size

6 × 5 × 2.25 mailer box prices6 × 4 × 3 mailer box prices7 × 5 × 3 mailer box prices8 × 6 × 3 mailer box prices12 × 9 × 2 mailer box prices9.5 × 7.75 × 4 mailer box prices10 × 8 × 4 mailer box prices12 × 10 × 4 mailer box prices14 × 10 × 4 mailer box pricesOpen the full comparison

More head to head

Packlane vs EcoEnclosePackhelp vs EcoEncloseArka vs EcoEncloseEcoEnclose vs VistaprintEcoEnclose vs UPrintingPacklane vs FantastapackPackhelp vs FantastapackArka vs FantastapackVistaprint vs FantastapackUPrinting vs Fantastapack

We may earn a commission from some suppliers. It never changes which suppliers appear or how they're ranked.How we make money